impure_tale: (the marquis disapproves of this shit)
impure_tale ([personal profile] impure_tale) wrote2010-04-18 04:52 pm

General Notice

Admiral, Iago's bed and books are to be removed from his chambers. A simple straw mattress will suffice.

Monsieur Sofer, if you are still experiencing shortages in the kitchen, feel free to add my Inmate to any shifts he does not already attend, and I want him on nightly cleanup. If he misses a shift, he is not to be fed.

My Inmate is not to be found anywhere within the vicinity of either the Master, or Judas Iscariot, without my prior sanction.

[identity profile] major-west.livejournal.com 2010-04-19 12:29 am (UTC)(link)
I don't know how I would have behaved in their shoes. It depends on what I saw to be the greater good.

What I do know is that stripping away the few things that ground some of us to humanity is a piss-poor way of fostering good behaviour. Loved ones should not be used as tools for punishment.

If Morgan responded to my actions in the same way you've responded to Iago's-- and I'm not talking about the work duty or the stripping of luxuries-- I would feel less inclined to follow her. I respect her too much to believe that she would use Billy as collateral against me.

[identity profile] impure-tale.livejournal.com 2010-04-19 12:31 am (UTC)(link)
Nothing the Master does is for the greater good, and you're an idiot for comparing those situations.

Right now they've been three years away from this place, and they need time to resettle. If they are constantly together and undermining that in the initial part, it could be damaging, and enough damage has been done already.

If you, Henry, or Billy had spent three years helping a madman subjugate an entire colony of people, tortured and killed countless, and the other of you simply stood back and condoned it? Never questioned? And one never would have acted without the other backing them up?

That makes the two mutually culpable, and that is NOT love.
Edited 2010-04-19 00:33 (UTC)

[identity profile] major-west.livejournal.com 2010-04-19 12:38 am (UTC)(link)
I never once brought him into this, so why don't you stop conflating the issue to try to appear right? You asked about death, and I answered, not death PLUS THE MASTER.

You know I've killed people pursuing what I believed to be right. And you know that I've done things that many would consider horrific and unjust. Billy hasn't judged me for it, and in the event of the riot, in which people have died, he did support me. We absolutely enabled each other, and we are in love, not whatever it is you believe it to be when two criminals find in each other what everybody else is entitled to. Had the wardens decided to punish us afterwards by keeping us separated, we would have gotten worse, not better.

You have no idea what's happened in those years. You're just upset that your authority has been undermined. They can make progress without being separated.

Oh, and need I remind you of the mirror flood? You know, the one where they sought to punish the both of us by restricting our access to one another?
Edited 2010-04-19 00:45 (UTC)

[identity profile] impure-tale.livejournal.com 2010-04-19 12:48 am (UTC)(link)
I'm not conflating the issue; the two of you seem perfectly amenable to comparing your situation to theirs. It's fair game.

There's a difference between pursuing what you believe to be right and acting on selfish whim.

I know the things that you have done, but I never doubted your sense of integrity, or that you believed that it would turn out for the betterment of everyone in the end. I never believed you acted maliciously. Iago has -- in his time here it has become especially apparent that Iago at times turns to violence on a whim. Sometimes without provocation. And he has been in a world where that has not only been permitted to go unchecked, but it's been encouraged, rewarded, and nurtured. He has been permitted to live this way, in a place where his actions have no consequence. And Judas has openly admitted, to my face, to enabling that. THAT is why I wanted them apart the first week.

I have never been afraid to tell you I have thought you were wrong in the past, Henry. Even when we were a good deal closer. Even when I was an Inmate. For that reason, I respect your choice to speak to me on the matter now, but I cannot agree with you.

You mean the mirror flood where they sought to punish me by restricting my access to ANYONE, much less a toilet, clean water, and fresh air? Yes, I remember. It's an inappropriate comparison.
Edited 2010-04-19 00:50 (UTC)

[identity profile] major-west.livejournal.com 2010-04-19 12:58 am (UTC)(link)
Because it could just as easily be us in their position one day! None of you have any right to dangle our loved ones over our heads like a carrot on a stick.

Then perhaps you should have stated that in the first place, rather than making a demand that appears indefinite. While I still disagree with keeping them apart like this, a week is a lot easier to stomach than what you demanded in this entry.

And I stand by what I said. I will not enable your demands; if I see them with each other, I, at least, will not stop them.
Edited 2010-04-19 00:59 (UTC)

[identity profile] impure-tale.livejournal.com 2010-04-19 01:01 am (UTC)(link)
I never said the change was permanent. Merely until further notice.

And Iago may see Judas once he has completed his first day of service, as I have also said.

I respect your decision and I understand why.

[identity profile] major-west.livejournal.com 2010-04-19 01:32 am (UTC)(link)
Thank you for listening to my thoughts on the matter, at the very least. I really do hope this does not backfire on you.